Game 4: Joke or Disqualification
Game 4: Joke or Disqualification
Objective: Train the “Covert Aggression Detector” to quickly distinguish between a friendly joke and a status attack, and react proportionally.
Players and Roles
- Role A (The Screenwriter): Reads phrases from a list (some neutral, others rude).
- Role B (The Detector): Classifies and responds.
Quick Set-up: The Script
The Screenwriter reads one of these phrases. The Detector must shout the color.
| Phrase | Tone / Intention | Correct Color |
|---|---|---|
| “Hey, that shirt looks good on you.” | Sincere / Compliment | GREEN |
| “Wow, how brave coming dressed like that…” | Sarcasm / Judgment | RED |
| “Pass me the salt, please?” | Neutral request | GREEN |
| “Let’s see if you learn to pass the salt without spilling it.” | Paternalism / Scolding | RED |
| “You look a bit tired, are you okay?” | Real concern | GREEN |
| “You look terrible today, don’t you?” | False concern / Attack | RED |
| “Thanks for the report, good job.” | Gratitude | GREEN |
| “Finally you deliver something decent.” | Praise with implicit insult | RED |
| “Can we talk for a moment?” | Conversation proposal | GREEN |
| “We need to talk (sigh)…” | Anxiety generation | RED |
Mechanics
- The Screenwriter says a phrase with ambiguous tone.
- Ex 1: “Some hair you have today”.
- Ex 2: “Thank goodness you are here, Einstein”.
- The Detector must shout “GREEN” (Friendly) or “RED” (Attack) in less than 2 seconds.
- If GREEN: Smile and continue.
- If RED: Launch a neutral meta-comment (“That comment is unnecessary”, “Where is that coming from?”, “I ignore the tone”).
Debriefing (Closing questions)
- Is it harder to detect or respond?
- Were you afraid of seeming “too sensitive” when marking a RED?
Variant
Play with eyes closed to guide yourself only by the tone of voice (paralanguage).
Train this theory
AI Sparring Partner
If you don’t have a human partner, copy and paste this prompt into ChatGPT/Claude to practice alone:
Act as a "Screenwriter of Ambiguous Tones". We are going to play "Covert Aggression Detector".
Your goal is to train my ability to distinguish between harmless comments and covert attacks.
RULES:
1. You generate short phrases that can be framed as "Green" (Sincere/Neutral) or "Red" (Passive-Aggressive/Sarcastic/Attack).
2. Examples of Red: "Wow, how brave coming dressed like that...", "Finally you deliver something decent."
3. Examples of Green: "Hey, that shirt looks good on you", "Thanks for the report."
4. I must classify them as GREEN or RED.
- If RED, I must also provide a Neutral Meta-comment response (e.g., "I ignore the tone").
5. If I classify correctly, say "✅ POINT" and give me another phrase.
6. If I fail (e.g., calling a compliment an attack), explain the nuance.
START THE CONVERSATION NOW BY:
1. Saying "Welcome to the Detector. Put on your radar."
2. Throwing the first ambiguous phrase.